« The Dalai Lama: Dumb and dumber | Main | Paul Scofield, RIP »
March 21, 2008
How to tell if a law is total garbage
By Nicholas Provenzo from The Rule of Reason,cross-posted by MetaBlogWhat is one way to tell that a law is utterly non-objective and deserves to be repealed? When the enforcement of the exact same law can radically change from one political administration to another. Consider this report that quotes an antitrust lawyer warning businesses to announce their mergers now, lest they run afoul of a potentially Democratic antitrust enforcement apparatus.
Phillip Zane, who specializes in antitrust matters for the law firm Baker Donelson, said that a Democratic administration was likely to take a tougher line on merger reviews than the Bush team.OK, that's probably true, but imagine if Mr. Phillip Zane esq. was a criminal attorney warning the public that a Democratic administration was likely to take a tougher line on murder. Most would recognize that different political administrations may seek more or less aggressive sentences for murder as punishment for having been convicted of committing it, but the actual definition of what constitutes murder under the law remains the same regardless of administration.
"If I had any sort of close deal, I'd rather have it go now," Zane said. "It may be that some of the airline deals are close deals." [Diane Bartz Reuters]
Such is not the case for antitrust enforcement; antitrust law is so vague that political administrations can and do diverge greatly over what constitutes "restraint of trade" or the "attempt to monopolize." Right then and there this wild divergence ought to signal that the law is utterly un-objective and unfair. How can one possibly hope to avoid running afoul of a law that changes with the political winds? And worse, why would one continue to tolerate it?
Originally posted by Nicholas Provenzo from The Rule of Reason, ReBlogged for Meta Blog
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.objectivismonline.net/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/1323
Comments
Post a comment
Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)
